The One-Room Schoolhouse in Prison Classrooms

In the age of modern education, the one-room schoolhouse might seem like a relic of the past. However, for educators working in prisons, the concept of teaching students of varying ages and educational levels in one classroom mirrors this historic model. The unique setting of prison education, where students range from individuals with minimal literacy skills to those pursuing high school diplomas or beyond, necessitates a creative and adaptable teaching approach.

In the traditional one-room schoolhouse, students of various ages and abilities learned together in a single space under the guidance of one teacher. This teacher had to balance teaching basic reading and math skills to younger students while engaging older students in more advanced topics. Similarly, in prison education, students may have vastly different educational backgrounds, abilities, and goals. This requires prison educators to adopt flexible instructional practices that allow all students to progress at their own pace. But how do we manage such diverse needs in one classroom? Here are some effective strategies for differentiating instruction in this dynamic environment.

1. Assess and Group Students by Skill Level

The first step to successfully managing a diverse classroom is understanding the skill levels of your students. Begin with diagnostic assessments to determine where each student stands in core subjects such as reading, writing, and math. Once you have a clear understanding of their abilities, group students by similar skill levels. These groups can be flexible and shift as students progress. Grouping allows you to tailor instruction more effectively, providing targeted support for students who need it while challenging those who are ready for more advanced material.

2. Implement Tiered Assignments

Tiered assignments involve offering different levels of work on the same topic to match students' readiness levels. For example, if you’re teaching a lesson on fractions, one group of students might work on identifying and comparing simple fractions, while another group focuses on adding and subtracting fractions with like denominators. This approach keeps all students engaged with the same overarching topic but allows them to work at their appropriate level of challenge.

3. Use Learning Stations and Choice Menus

Learning stations are a powerful way to keep students engaged while providing individualized instruction. Set up different areas in the classroom where students can work on various tasks. For example, one station might focus on literacy skills such as reading comprehension or vocabulary building, while another emphasizes math practice. Rotating through stations allows students to engage with multiple subjects during class time, reinforcing skills in a variety of ways and giving you the opportunity to work one-on-one with students when needed. Choice menus allow students to choose assignments that match their learning style and level of understanding.

4. Incorporate Self-Paced Learning

Many students in prison education settings benefit from the autonomy of self-paced learning. Whether through workbooks, online modules, or individual projects, giving students the ability to progress at their own speed helps them take ownership of their learning. For those at a lower skill level, this may mean working through foundational materials, while more advanced students can push themselves with challenging content. As the teacher, your role is to provide guidance, feedback, and encouragement as they move forward. Adult students particularly do well with autonomous learning activities.

5. Leverage Peer Teaching and Collaboration

In a one-room schoolhouse, older or more advanced students often helped younger or less experienced learners. This concept can be powerful in the prison classroom as well. Encourage peer teaching by pairing students together for collaborative work. More advanced students can serve as mentors or tutors, explaining concepts and assisting those who are struggling. This not only reinforces the more advanced student’s learning but also builds a sense of community and mutual support within the classroom.

6. Flexible Lesson Plans with Scaffolding

Planning lessons with built-in flexibility is key when working with a diverse group of learners. Incorporate scaffolding techniques, such as providing sentence starters for writing assignments or using visual aids and manipulatives for math instruction. This allows students who need more support to have the tools they need to succeed, while those ready for a challenge can work more independently. Scaffolding should be gradually removed as students gain confidence and proficiency.

7. Foster a Growth Mindset

Many students in prison settings have experienced failure in traditional education systems. It’s essential to foster a growth mindset in your classroom, emphasizing that intelligence and ability are not fixed traits but can be developed with effort and persistence. Celebrate small successes and encourage students to view challenges as opportunities for growth. This mindset shift can be transformative, motivating students to persevere even when faced with difficult material.

The one-room schoolhouse model may seem like a distant memory, but for teachers in prisons, it remains a relevant and necessary approach to education. By differentiating instruction and employing creative strategies, we can ensure that all students, regardless of their starting point, have the opportunity to learn, grow, and succeed. In this environment, the flexibility, patience, and innovation of the teacher are as important as ever.

By embracing the diverse educational needs of our students and providing them with the tools they need to thrive, we can help them develop the skills that will serve them long after they leave the classroom—and the prison walls. This approach not only improves educational outcomes but also plays a crucial role in the broader goals of reentry preparation.

If you’d like some ideas on differentiated instruction, you can contact me here.

I hope you’re enjoying your Sunday Morning Coffee (the blog AND your cup o’joe)! Here’s to an educational, adventurous, peaceful (insert your favorite adjective here) week. Tallyho!